Case Studies

Simplifying Healthcare Compliance: A Case Study on HAIEC Core's Checklist Success

2026-01-296 min read

Share:

This case study demonstrates how a 200-bed community hospital simplified HIPAA compliance, reduced audit preparation time by 85%, and achieved 100% compliance using HAIEC Core's automated checklist system.

Organization Profile

Community General Hospital

Overview:

Size: 200 beds
Staff: 800 employees
Location: Midwest United States
Annual revenue: $150M
Patients: 50,000/year

Compliance requirements:

HIPAA Security Rule
HIPAA Privacy Rule
HITECH Act
State privacy laws
Joint Commission standards
CMS requirements

Challenges:

Manual compliance tracking
Decentralized documentation
Audit preparation: 8 weeks
Compliance violations: 12/year
Staff turnover: High

The Challenge

Pre-HAIEC Compliance State

Manual processes:

Excel spreadsheet tracking
Paper-based checklists
Email-based evidence collection
Quarterly manual audits
Reactive approach

Resource requirements:

Compliance team: 3 FTE
Annual hours: 6,000+
Audit preparation: 8 weeks
Cost: $400,000/year

Pain points:

Incomplete visibility
Delayed issue detection
Manual evidence gathering
Inconsistent processes
Audit stress

Specific Problems

Access control:

200+ terminated users still active
No systematic access reviews
Excessive permissions common
Manual deprovisioning (3-5 days)

Training compliance:

15% overdue training
Manual tracking
No automated reminders
Incomplete records

Risk assessments:

Annual only
3 months to complete
Outdated by completion
Limited scope

Incident response:

Average detection: 45 days
Manual reporting
Inconsistent investigation
Poor documentation

Implementation Journey

Phase 1: Assessment (Month 1)

Activities:

Current state analysis
Gap identification
HAIEC configuration
Integration planning

Findings:

47 compliance gaps identified
200+ control deficiencies
$2M potential penalty exposure
85% manual processes

Cost: $15,000 (consultant + setup)

Phase 2: Integration (Month 2)

Systems integrated:

Epic EHR
Active Directory
AWS infrastructure
Okta (SSO)
ServiceNow (ticketing)
Learning management system

Configuration:

150+ automated checks
Evidence collection rules
Alert thresholds
Workflow automation

Time: 80 hours (IT team)

Phase 3: Policy Migration (Month 3)

Policies digitized:

Information security (25 pages)
Privacy procedures (40 pages)
Incident response (15 pages)
Business continuity (30 pages)
Vendor management (20 pages)

Conversion:

Manual policies → Automated checklists
Static documents → Dynamic workflows
Annual reviews → Continuous monitoring

Time: 120 hours (compliance team)

Phase 4: Training and Rollout (Month 4)

Training delivered:

Compliance team: 16 hours
IT team: 8 hours
Department heads: 4 hours
All staff: 2 hours (online)

Rollout:

Pilot department (Month 3)
Full deployment (Month 4)
Optimization (Months 5-6)

Adoption rate: 95% within 30 days

Results Achieved

Compliance Improvements

Access control:

Terminated users: 200 → 0
Access reviews: Manual → Automated (quarterly)
Deprovisioning: 3-5 days → 4 hours
Excessive permissions: -80%

Training compliance:

Overdue training: 15% → 0%
Tracking: Automated
Reminders: Automatic
Completion rate: 100%

Risk assessments:

Frequency: Annual → Continuous
Completion time: 3 months → Real-time
Coverage: +200%
Accuracy: +40%

Incident response:

Detection time: 45 days → 2 hours
Reporting: Automated
Investigation: Standardized
Documentation: Complete

Operational Efficiency

Time savings:

Compliance team: 6,000 → 900 hours/year (-85%)
Audit preparation: 8 weeks → 1 week (-87%)
Risk assessments: 3 months → Real-time (-100%)
Evidence collection: 400 → 40 hours/year (-90%)

Cost reduction:

Compliance operations: $400K → $80K/year
Audit costs: $50K → $20K/year
Violations/penalties: $200K → $20K/year
Total savings: $530K/year

Audit Performance

Before HAIEC:

Audit findings: 12 gaps
Preparation time: 8 weeks
Auditor hours: 120
Report quality: Fair

After HAIEC:

Audit findings: 1 gap
Preparation time: 1 week
Auditor hours: 40
Report quality: Excellent

Improvement: -92% findings, -87% prep time

Risk Reduction

Compliance violations:

Before: 12/year
After: 1/year
Reduction: -92%

Potential penalties:

Before: $2M exposure
After: $200K exposure
Reduction: -90%

Breach risk:

Detection time: -96%
Response time: -80%
Impact reduction: -70%

Key Success Factors

1. Executive Support

CEO commitment:

Budget approval
Resource allocation
Staff accountability
Public endorsement

Impact: 95% adoption rate

2. Phased Approach

Strategy:

Pilot department first
Learn and adjust
Gradual rollout
Continuous optimization

Result: Smooth implementation

3. Automation Focus

Automated:

Evidence collection (90%)
Control testing (85%)
Reporting (95%)
Remediation workflows (70%)

Benefit: Sustainable compliance

4. Change Management

Communication:

Regular updates
Success stories
Training support
Feedback loops

Adoption: 95% within 30 days

Financial Analysis

Investment

Year 1 costs:

HAIEC subscription: $7,200
Implementation: $15,000
Training: $10,000
Integration: $8,000
Total: $40,200

Annual ongoing:

HAIEC subscription: $7,200
Maintenance: $5,000
Total: $12,200/year

Return on Investment

Annual savings:

Compliance operations: $320,000
Audit costs: $30,000
Violations avoided: $180,000
Total: $530,000/year

ROI calculation:

Year 1:
Investment: $40,200
Savings: $530,000
Net benefit: $489,800
ROI: 1,119%
Payback: 0.9 months

Year 2+:
Investment: $12,200
Savings: $530,000
Net benefit: $517,800
ROI: 4,144%

5-Year Projection

Total investment: $89,000 Total savings: $2,650,000 Net benefit: $2,561,000 ROI: 2,778%

Lessons Learned

What Worked Well

Automation:

Eliminated manual tracking
Reduced human error
Ensured consistency
Enabled scalability

Integration:

Single source of truth
Real-time data
Reduced duplication
Improved accuracy

Continuous monitoring:

Proactive issue detection
Faster remediation
Better compliance
Reduced audit stress

Challenges Overcome

Initial resistance:

Solution: Training and communication
Result: 95% adoption

Integration complexity:

Solution: Phased approach
Result: Successful integration

Process changes:

Solution: Change management
Result: Smooth transition

Recommendations for Others

1. Start with Gap Assessment

Understand:

Current state
Compliance gaps
Resource requirements
Expected ROI

2. Secure Executive Buy-In

Demonstrate:

Business case
ROI projection
Risk reduction
Competitive advantage

3. Plan for Change

Invest in:

Communication
Training
Support
Feedback

4. Measure and Optimize

Track:

Compliance metrics
Efficiency gains
Cost savings
User satisfaction

Conclusion

Community General Hospital achieved 1,119% first-year ROI by implementing HAIEC Core's automated compliance system. The hospital reduced compliance costs by 80%, audit preparation time by 87%, and violations by 92%.

Key results:

Time savings: 85%
Cost reduction: 80%
Violations: -92%
Audit findings: -92%
ROI: 1,119% (Year 1)

Investment: $40,200 (Year 1), $12,200/year ongoing Savings: $530,000/year Payback: 0.9 months

Ready to simplify your healthcare compliance? Schedule demo →

Related Resources